Minstrel Banjo

For enthusiasts of early banjo

Mark Weems's version of Mister Banjo inspired me to finally purchase Slave Songs of the United States 1867. I found O'er the Crossing, derived in Caroline County where I live. So, I decided to try to tab it out. Mind you, I don't read music. But, I impressed myself because I think I have some pretty good bones for it, but I'm pretty sure I messed up the higher parts. It seems to fit the minstrel tuning really well. That said, does anyone have a tab or recording for it? I haven't seen any on the Google machine. Anything at this point would be a help.

Views: 113

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Rob, the book has it written out in the key of Aflat (Ab).  What key are you tabbing/playing it transposed to?  

Here you can buy/listen to the song transposed to key of C (with I think an accidental Bb not in it- (not 'accidental' as in 'mistake').  The sample clip starts within the first whole measure of the more tricky B part (second part) BTW.

Andrew Calhoun and Campground album "Bound to Go" 

Probably worth buying the whole album.  It has more than one song from the "Slave Songs" book, which has a large number of gospel songs in it.

--- IF you are trying to play the B part in the key of G (which has one #...F# in it), then that phrase the the sample clip starts with would be the notes: D-F#-D-F(F natural)-G-E  (these notes corresponding to the lyrics "I do believe.. We're a "   Hope this helps?

Thanks for the album recommendation!! It's definitely going in the cart...

I'm tuned to eAEG#B (a step above Briggs). My banjo is just better in this tuning than Briggs. Anyways, I thought it fit well into the open 2d string w/ all the G#'s. Now that you mention Ab, moving things down a half step would definitely put my fingers in "standard" position for that drop tuning.

Now that I have some more info, I'm going to go rework that and see what I can come up with...

Thanks again!!

I'd recommend you go into Briggs  key of G simply to make it simpler to figure this song out.  After you have it tabbed out or can play it by ear, then you can tune all your strings up and down and see if it plays ok from there.   

Remember, simply changing the pitch of a tuning evenly across all strings (like going from eAEG#B -"low bass" key of A...to dGDF#A -"low bass" key of G)  doesn't change your fingering.  But changing the actual intervals between the strings- changing to a 'different' tuning (as in low bass vs high bass) DOES then change the fingering and often the key, and it very much effects what finger moves and sharps and flats you might need to play for a tune.  Could make it difficult or more easy.

It wouldn't make it 'easier' simply pitched down a half step from eAEG#B to Ab... you'd still be using the same fingering as any low bass tuning, like Briggs in G or A.  It'd just make it harder to help you when we're referring to the notes.   ;)

I think I follow what you're saying. Play with both and figure out which is better...

Apologies for not being able to speak intelligently about music. But, I can sure I-IV-V the heck out of a tune!! LOL So, I tend to refer to everything in terms of standard G...I kind of have my own little bastard language, which is why I have to think waaaay too hard about some of this stuff, when it's saying the same thing, just more correct...
I have been giving this a wack too, all the flats throwing me off quite a bit.

So purchase Andrew Calhoun's sung version (for 99 cents if you don't want the whole album), and use some software like Amazing Slowdowner to change the key from C (the key he is singing it in) to other keys you typically use on your banjo... and pick out the melody on your banjo to see if it lies better in G or D on your Briggs-tuned banjo.

i don't think I'm too far from it. It's just little twiddly bits to keep it from sounding so droll. I typically need both the tab and to hear it and go from there. In typical folk songs, you can get away fudging some things or "making your own version. But with a lot of the minstrel music (esp the books -- Briggs, Converse, etc), you can't quite afford to do that.

Particularly in this tune, it's the odd or unexpected phrases and notes (the ones that don't go where you normally would expect them to) that are essential to give the tune its unique character and identity. 

Ahhh okay that helps to know notes are not in usual places on banjo. I couldn't get it to sound banjoish at all which is why I am doubting myself.

One time my banjo teacher had me transcribing this monstrous fiddle tune, the name escapes me but I had a hell of a time doing it and when I returned to review my tabs he laughed and told me some tunes aren't meant to be transcribed to banjo haha

Reply to Discussion



John Masciale created this Ning Network.

© 2019   Created by John Masciale.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service