I had the good fortune of meeting Mark Wingate on the internet this week. He was kind enough to share the Buckley Fiddle Book of 1855. This is interesting on many levels. First, it is another look at one of our greatest contributors to Stroke Style banjo playing...Mr. James Buckley. The dating of the book, and the cross referenced tunes gives us yet another view of how this early banjo repertoire was put together. I don't know how well these fit into the fiddle stylings of the day, but the link to the banjo, as Buckley showed us time and again, is unmistakable. Tunes that share the same music with a different title in Buckley's New Banjo Method of 1860-
Bang Up Jig (fiddle 1855) and Dick Sliter's Reel (1860)
Black Bird Jig (fiddle 1855) and Jake Bacchus' Jig (1860)
Unkown Jig (fiddle 1855) and Fisher's Jig (1860)
Billy Day (fiddle 1855) and The Newton Jig (1860)
Even these are cross referenced in Ryan's Mammoth with other titles...and no variation in the music.
Now, notice the contibution of one Tom Briggs in this book. Alabama Jig could very well have fit into the Rice Book, with lots of thumb playing, and those triplet figures that include an open string pull instead of a finger glide. Banjo tunes...or fiddle tunes??? Or doesn't it really matter all in all? The Buckley material always lacked fingerings and direction. This is the source of his some of his 1860 book. Did he just have a huge stockpile of music, and dispensed it as he saw fit?
Let's play some of these. I would suggest "Alabama Jig" and "Banjo Jig" by Briggs.