Hah! Actually, when I was looking at the Keel Row reel in the book, I was working out the dance instructions written underneath. Since John and I were dance masters at a ball I was debating having everyone dance the reel as my arrangement!
Tim, I'm sorry my answer took so long. Since I don't clog, I don't really know. I found an 1870s book on clogging on Google books, but no preview. So I checked YouTube. I like this clogging video http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ql1nQBwbz8U
It's a nice easy tempo. The problem with dance tempos is how much they vary. For example, an Irish step dance will do a reel at a different tempo than I would want it at a Civil War ball. I think being able to breath while dancing is important. :) Hope that's some help, wish I could be more definitive!
Hats off to Tim and Carl. I was having fits over playing that far up on the neck, particularly measures 3&4. Both of you used the same fingering, which looks fairly clean. I'm going to have to practice my way through that for a few weeks...
It is a fun tune, it stands up to either a moderate or quick tempo.
Great job guys. John, I think that fixed position makes those passages easier. Carl jumped down for the final notes of the phrase, but we seemed lock into the other stuff about the same. A smoking tempo there Sam. John, I think I heard a few quotes in there. Did you create a written arrangement of what you did? I totally enjoyed seeing the different approaches this week.
The relationship of the fiddle repertoire and early banjo keeps getting clearer and clearer to me. Can't wait for next week's tune....whatever it is. Any ideas?